Quebec · National Assembly of Quebec; overseen by the Commission d'accès à l'information (CAI)
Quebec Law 25, s. 12.1 (automated decisions)
Quebec Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, s. 12.1 (automated decision notice, from Law 25)
Section 12.1 of Quebec’s Law 25 has been in force since September 22, 2023. If a decision about you is made only by automated processing of your personal information, the organisation must tell you, and on request explain the information used, the main reasons, and your right to have the data corrected.
Figures as of November 1, 2026.Mitey, data editor · Evidence checked Status checked against the official sources listed below.
In force since September 22, 2023. Whether it binds federally chartered banks is not settled; it applies to Quebec-regulated institutions such as Desjardins.
Next milestone
None — in force
The editor’s read
Why does it matter for AI in banking?
This is the strongest automated-decision right in force in Canada. It clearly applies to Quebec-regulated institutions such as Desjardins. Whether it binds federally chartered banks is not settled, so most large banks describe automated decisions in their privacy notices without conceding that it applies.
If you live in Quebec and a decision was fully automated, you can ask for the reasons and for a person to review it. Our account page has a letter you can adapt.
In practice, Desjardins is the institution in this Index most clearly bound, and its privacy policy says some requests may be decided automatically, with notice. Federally chartered banks serving Quebec customers describe automated decisions in their privacy notices too, which this Index counts under transparency, without conceding that section 12.1 applies to them. If you are refused credit online in Quebec, asking whether the decision was fully automated is the first step to using this right.

What are the key dates?
s. 12.1 comes into force
What does it mean for bank customers?
If a business decides something about you based only on automated processing of your personal information, it must tell you no later than when it tells you the decision. On request it must say what information it used, the reasons and main factors behind the decision, and that you can have the data corrected, and you can present your views to a staff member who can review the decision.
What does it mean for banks?
Fully automated decisions such as instant credit declines for Quebec customers need a notice and an explanation-and-review process. Whether s. 12.1 binds federally chartered banks (versus PIPEDA) is a constitutional question not verified here; it clearly applies to Quebec-regulated institutions such as financial cooperatives.
Which institutions in the Index does it touch?
Quebec-regulated institutions in the Index.
| Institution | Evidence | Index score |
|---|---|---|
| Desjardins | Model-risk framework covers AI · names the AMF guideline | 54 |
What does it ask for, and who already publishes it?
Each line paraphrases one expectation from the official sources. Where the Index measures something close, the last column counts the institutions in scope (quebec-regulated institutions in the index) that publish it, each linked to its source on their profile.
| What it asks | Closest Index criterion | Institutions that publish it |
|---|---|---|
| Tell the person when a decision was made only by automated processingRequired no later than when the decision is communicated. | Tells customers when AI or automated decisions are used | 1 of 1Desjardins |
| On request, give the information used and the main reasons and factorsThe explanation right in force in Quebec. | Not measured by the Index | — |
| Let the person have the information correctedFixing wrong inputs can change the outcome. | Not measured by the Index | — |
| Let the person submit observations to someone who can review the decisionA human review route. | Not measured by the Index | — |
The checklist above, counted from the published Index data. Every number can be rechecked from the criteria CSV.
| Institutions in scope | 1Quebec-regulated institutions in the Index |
|---|---|
| Checklist items | 41 matched to an Index criterion |
| Items published, across all institutions in scope | 1 of 1One point for each institution that publishes each measured item |
| Most items published by one institution | Desjardins: 1 of 1 |
| Share of measured items published | 100%1 of 1 institution publishes every measured item |
What do the key terms mean?
- AI system (AIS)
- The AMF uses the OECD definition: a machine-based system that infers from its inputs how to generate outputs such as predictions, content, recommendations or decisions.
- Risk-based classification
- Sorting each AI system by how much harm it could cause, so riskier systems get stricter controls.
- Fair treatment of clients
- The AMF’s commercial-practice expectation that institutions deal with clients fairly; AI use is held to the same standard.
What this means for you
- It applies now.
- To see what your own bank has disclosed about AI and your rights today, use What AI touches my account?
- To complain about an AI-assisted decision, start with your bank’s complaint process; our guide on complaining about a bank AI decision has the steps.
Questions about Quebec Law 25, s. 12.1 (automated decisions)
What is the status of Quebec Law 25, s. 12.1 (automated decisions)?
In force since September 22, 2023. Whether it binds federally chartered banks is not settled; it applies to Quebec-regulated institutions such as Desjardins.
What should I ask for if a decision was automated?
Ask whether the decision was made only by automated processing, what personal information was used, the main reasons and factors, and for a person who can review it. Our account page has a letter you can adapt.
Does it cover decisions where a human was involved?
Section 12.1 covers decisions based exclusively on automated processing. A meaningful human review takes a decision outside it.
Who enforces it?
The Commission d’accès à l’information du Québec (CAI).
Sources (official first)
Change log
Status verified against the official sources: In force since September 22, 2023. Whether it binds federally chartered banks is not settled; it applies to Quebec-regulated institutions such as Desjardins.
Related rules
- AMF guideline on AI (Quebec) · coming
Status as checked on November 1, 2026. Laws and guidance change; check the official source before relying on a date.
