Skip to content

    Federal (Canada) · Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI)

    OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk)

    OSFI Guideline E-23 – Model Risk Management (2027)

    Short answer

    OSFI Guideline E-23 is the federal model-risk rule for banks and other federally regulated lenders. The final version was published September 11, 2025 and takes effect May 1, 2027. It expressly covers AI and machine-learning models, so the algorithms behind credit, pricing and fraud decisions need documented oversight and monitoring.

    Figures as of November 1, 2026.

    Mitey, data editor · Evidence checked Status checked against the official sources listed below.

    Coming

    Final, published September 11, 2025. Takes effect May 1, 2027, and expressly covers AI and machine-learning models.

    Next milestone

    E-23 effective for federally regulated financial institutions

    181 days to go

    The editor’s read

    Why does it matter for AI in banking?

    E-23 is the closest thing Canada has to a binding AI rule for banks. It does not ban any use of AI; it makes each federally regulated institution keep an inventory of its models, rate their risk, validate them independently and monitor them once they are live, with AI and machine-learning models explicitly in scope.

    Most large institutions in the Index already say their model-risk frameworks cover AI. What will change on May 1, 2027 is that supervisors can test it. For customers, the practical effect is indirect but real: a bank must be able to explain how a model that decides your credit limit or flags your payment was built and checked.

    Mitey the yeti at a desk with a laptop and a checklist
    Mitey checked 19 institutions in the Index against OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk), using each one’s own published evidence.

    What are the key dates?

    1. Final guideline published

    2. Guideline takes effect

    What does it mean for bank customers?

    The models your bank uses to approve credit, set prices or flag fraud, including AI and machine-learning models, will need documented oversight, bias checks and ongoing monitoring. You will not see the guideline directly, but it is the main federal rule that makes a bank answer for how its algorithms behave.

    What does it mean for banks?

    Federally regulated institutions need an enterprise model inventory, risk ratings and lifecycle controls (design, independent review, approval, deployment, monitoring, decommissioning) that explicitly cover AI/ML, explainability and model drift. Requirements scale with the institution's size and complexity, and heavy use of advanced AI is expected to be matched by more mature governance.

    Which institutions in the Index does it touch?

    Federally regulated institutions: does their model-risk framework already cover AI?.

    Federally regulated institutions: does their model-risk framework already cover AI?
    InstitutionEvidenceIndex score
    TDFramework covers AI/ML · E-23 not named84
    RBCFramework covers AI/ML · names E-2381
    CIBCFramework covers AI/ML · names E-2380
    National BankFramework covers AI/ML · names E-2369
    BMOFramework covers AI/ML · E-23 not named57
    ScotiabankAI coverage not stated · names E-2355
    EQ BankAI coverage not stated · names E-2342
    TangerineAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named21
    Coast CapitalFramework covers AI/ML · E-23 not named17
    SimpliiAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named13
    Canadian Tire BankAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named10
    Laurentian BankAI coverage not stated · names E-238
    Manulife BankAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named5
    VancityAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named3
    AlternaAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named0
    Central 1AI coverage not stated · E-23 not named0
    Home TrustAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named0
    PC FinancialAI coverage not stated · E-23 not named0
    Tru (First West)AI coverage not stated · E-23 not named0

    What does it ask for, and who already publishes it?

    Each line paraphrases one expectation from the official sources. Where the Index measures something close, the last column counts the institutions in scope (federally regulated institutions) that publish it, each linked to its source on their profile.

    OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk): checklist against Index evidence
    What it asksClosest Index criterionInstitutions that publish it
    Treat AI and machine-learning methods as models under the model-risk frameworkThis is the change that brings AI inside the rule.Says its own model-risk framework covers AI/ML6 of 19TD, RBC, CIBC, National Bank, BMO, Coast Capital
    Keep a model inventory and rate each model’s riskRiskier models, such as credit decisions, get more scrutiny.Not measured by the Index—
    Validate models independently before and after they go liveCatches drift and bias that the builders miss.Not measured by the Index—
    Give the board and senior management clear accountability for model riskSomeone senior answers for the algorithm.Discloses board or committee oversight of AI4 of 19TD, RBC, CIBC, National Bank
    Name an executive responsible for AINot required by E-23 itself, but the clearest public sign of accountability.Names an executive accountable for AI7 of 19TD, RBC, CIBC, National Bank, BMO, Scotiabank, EQ Bank
    Disclose readiness for E-23 in annual reportingInvestors and customers can see the bank is preparing.Names OSFI E-23, or the AMF equivalent for Quebec-regulated institutions6 of 19RBC, CIBC, National Bank, Scotiabank, EQ Bank, Laurentian Bank
    How ready are institutions for OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk)?

    The checklist above, counted from the published Index data. Every number can be rechecked from the criteria CSV.

    How ready are institutions for OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk)?: inputs, steps and result
    Institutions in scope19Federally regulated institutions
    Checklist items64 matched to an Index criterion
    Items published, across all institutions in scope23 of 76One point for each institution that publishes each measured item
    Most items published by one institutionRBC: 4 of 4
    Share of measured items published30%3 of 19 institutions publish every measured item

    Open the scorecard →

    What do the key terms mean?

    Model
    Under E-23, any method that turns data into an estimate, forecast or decision, explicitly including AI and machine-learning methods.
    Model risk
    The chance of loss or harm from a model that is wrong, misused or poorly controlled, for example a credit model that drifts after launch.
    Validation
    An independent check, before and after a model goes live, that it works as intended for the data it sees.

    What this means for you

    Questions about OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk)

    What is the status of OSFI Guideline E-23 (model risk)?

    Final, published September 11, 2025. Takes effect May 1, 2027, and expressly covers AI and machine-learning models.

    Does E-23 apply to credit unions?

    Only to federally regulated ones, such as Coast Capital and Tru Cooperative Bank. Provincially regulated credit unions follow their provincial regulator; Desjardins follows the AMF’s own model-risk and AI guidelines.

    Does E-23 give me a right to an explanation?

    No. It sets duties for the institution and its supervisor. Rights to an explanation come from privacy law, such as Quebec’s Law 25, and would expand under Bill C-36 if it passes.

    Sources (official first)

    1. Guideline E-23 – Model Risk Management (2027)

    Change log

    1. Status verified against the official sources: Final, published September 11, 2025. Takes effect May 1, 2027, and expressly covers AI and machine-learning models.

    Status as checked on November 1, 2026. Laws and guidance change; check the official source before relying on a date.

    Get the quarterly Canadian Bank AI Index update

    New scores, new deployments and rule changes, once a quarter from the MITEY Network. Unsubscribe any time.

    Educational information only, not financial, legal or privacy advice. Index scores measure public evidence, not service, safety or fairness. If you think you have been scammed, contact your financial institution right away and report it to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre at 1-888-495-8501. Last reviewed November 1, 2026.