Skip to content

    Guide · Your rights · Consumers

    Quebec Law 25 and automated decisions: what section 12.1 gives you

    Short answer

    Section 12.1 requires a business that makes a decision based exclusively on automated processing to tell you, no later than when it tells you the decision. On request, you can learn the information used, the reasons and principal factors, and have errors corrected, and you can present your observations to a staff member who can review it.

    Figures as of November 3, 2026.

    Since September 22, 2023, Quebec's private-sector privacy law has required businesses to tell people when a decision about them is based exclusively on automated processing. It's a rule written specifically for automated decisions, which makes it worth understanding even if you live outside Quebec. Here's what it says, who it may apply to and how to use it.

    Reviewed

    Key takeaways

    • Section 12.1 of Quebec's private-sector privacy act has been in force since September 22, 2023.
    • It covers decisions based exclusively on automated processing. The business must tell you no later than when it tells you the decision.
    • On request, you can learn the personal information used, the reasons and principal factors and parameters, and your right to have the information corrected.
    • You must get a chance to present your observations to a staff member who is in a position to review the decision.
    • Whether it applies to a federally regulated bank can be complex. Ask the business and the CAI rather than assuming.
    Using s. 12.1, rung by rung
    1. 1Watch for the noticeNo later than when you're told the decisionA business that makes a decision based exclusively on automated processing must tell you so.
    2. 2Ask what information was usedRequest the personal information the system used to make the decision.
    3. 3Ask for the reasonsRequest the reasons and the principal factors and parameters that led to the decision.
    4. 4Correct what is wrongAsk to have inaccurate personal information corrected, and send evidence.
    5. 5Present your observationsAsk to put your side to a staff member who is in a position to review the decision.
    6. 6Escalate if neededBank complaints: 56 days before OBSIUse the business's complaint process, then contact the CAI. Bank customers can also go to OBSI.

    What does section 12.1 say?

    Law 25 is the name commonly used for the Quebec law that modernized the province's privacy rules. One of its changes is section 12.1 of Quebec's private-sector privacy act, the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (in French, the Loi sur la protection des renseignements personnels dans le secteur privé). According to the Commission d'accès à l'information du Québec (CAI), section 12.1 came into force on September 22, 2023.

    Under s. 12.1, a business that uses personal information to make a decision based exclusively on automated processing must tell the person concerned. It must do so no later than when it tells them about the decision.

    Note the wording. The section is about decisions made by automated processing alone. It isn't a general rule about every use of AI, and it doesn't cover every decision a computer helped with.

    What can you ask for under section 12.1?

    On request, the business must also tell you:

    • the personal information used to make the decision
    • the reasons and the principal factors and parameters that led to the decision
    • your right to have the personal information used to make the decision corrected

    You can be heard by a person

    The business must give you the chance to present your observations to a member of its staff who is in a position to review the decision.

    What do these rights look like in practice?

    Put together, the section lets you ask what went into a decision, why it came out the way it did and how to fix information that's wrong, and then put your side to a person who can take another look.

    Suppose an online lender declines your application within seconds and tells you the decision was automated. You could ask which of your details the system used, what the main factors were (for example, income, existing debts or account history) and how to correct anything that's out of date. If you think the result is wrong, you could then ask to speak to someone who can review it, and explain what the system may have missed.

    The factors a business gives you won't necessarily be a full technical account of its model. If what you get back is too vague to help you understand the decision or spot errors, say so and ask follow-up questions. Ask the business when you can expect a reply, and keep a note of what it tells you.

    Mitey the yeti checks a phone showing a shield
    Asking whether a person or a system made the call is a simple question, and the answer shapes everything you do next.

    When is a decision exclusively automated, and when isn't it?

    Many systems mix automation and people. A model might score an application, and a staff member might then approve, decline or adjust the result. Whether that counts as a decision based exclusively on automated processing depends on the facts and on how the law is interpreted.

    Bank announcements show how mixed these processes can be. TD says its agentic AI for mortgage and HELOC applications classifies documents, extracts information and checks figures against select policies, then produces a summary memo for human underwriters. TD's release doesn't say the agents make final credit decisions. That describes TD's process; it says nothing about whether s. 12.1 applies to it.

    If you're unsure, ask directly: Was this decision made only by an automated system? If a person was involved, what was their role? The answer tells you whether to ask for the s. 12.1 information or to use another route, such as a complaint or an access request.

    Who does section 12.1 apply to?

    Section 12.1 is part of Quebec's private-sector privacy act, so it applies to businesses subject to that act. Working out which businesses that includes can be complex, especially for federally regulated organizations such as banks, which are also subject to federal privacy law.

    This guide doesn't take a position on whether s. 12.1 applies to any particular bank or decision. If it matters to you, ask the business which privacy law it applies to your situation, and contact the CAI, Quebec's access-to-information and privacy regulator, for guidance.

    Even where s. 12.1 doesn't apply, the questions it lists are reasonable ones to ask any business that uses automated decisions. You may not be entitled to every answer, but asking costs nothing.

    How does section 12.1 compare with the federal rules?

    Federal privacy law, PIPEDA, works through 10 general principles, such as consent, accuracy and individual access. Those principles apply to automated processing as they do to any other use of personal information, but PIPEDA doesn't set out a notice-and-review rule for automated decisions like s. 12.1. We have not found a federal rule that gives you a general right to reasons when an automated system refuses you credit, so don't assume one exists.

    Bill C-36, which had first reading in Parliament on June 15, 2026, proposes a federal right to an explanation of predictions, recommendations or decisions by automated decision systems that have significant effects. As of October 2026, it remains at second reading and is not law. Our PIPEDA guide covers the federal rights in force today.

    Automated-decision rules compared (as of October 2026)
    QuestionQuebec s. 12.1PIPEDABill C-36
    StatusIn force since Sept. 22, 2023In forceProposed; at second reading
    What it coversDecisions based exclusively on automated processingAll handling of personal information, through 10 principlesAutomated-system predictions, recommendations or decisions with significant effects
    What you can getInformation used, reasons and principal factors and parameters, correction, review by staffAccess to your information and correction of inaccuraciesA right to an explanation (proposed)
    Who to contactThe business, then the CAIThe organization, then the OPCNot applicable unless passed

    How do you use your section 12.1 rights?

    Start with the business. Ask in writing whether the decision was based exclusively on automated processing and, if so, request the information s. 12.1 describes. Keep copies and note the dates you sent and received each message.

    Check what comes back. If the information used is wrong or out of date, ask for it to be corrected and include evidence. Then ask to present your observations to a staff member who can review the decision, and say clearly what you'd like reconsidered.

    If you're a bank customer, you can also use your bank's complaint process. Banks must handle complaints within 56 days; after that, or once the bank's process is finished, you can go to OBSI, which has been the single external complaints body for banks since November 1, 2024. For Quebec privacy concerns, contact the CAI. The privacy rights explainer can help you sort out which route fits.

    From the Index: who tells customers about AI

    What the Canadian Bank AI Index shows on this topic, counted from the published data. Every number can be rechecked in the database.

    From the Index: who tells customers about AI: inputs, steps and result
    Institutions scored35Canadian Bank AI Index, 2026 Q4
    Supervised by OSFI19
    Tell customers when AI or automated decisions are used13Each with a public source on its profile
    Share of all institutions13 of 35 (37%)CIBC, Canadian Tire Bank, Desjardins, EQ Bank, National Bank, Neo, Questrade, RBC, Simplii, Tangerine, TD, Scotiabank, Wealthsimple

    Open the scorecard →Computed November 1, 2026.

    What this means for you

    • If a decision seems automated, ask in writing whether it was made only by an automated system and, if a person was involved, what their role was.
    • Request the personal information used and the principal factors and parameters. If the answer is too vague to help you spot errors, say so and ask follow-up questions.
    • Send evidence to correct anything out of date, then ask to present your observations to a staff member who is in a position to review the decision.
    • Whether s. 12.1 applies to a federally regulated bank can be complex, so ask the bank which privacy law it applies to your situation and contact the CAI for guidance.
    • Bank customers can also use the bank’s complaint process and then OBSI after 56 days; the privacy rights explainer can help you choose the route.

    How to ask a business about an automated decision under Quebec s. 12.1

    1. 1Confirm how the decision was madeAsk the business in writing whether the decision was based exclusively on automated processing, and which privacy law it applies to your situation.
    2. 2Request the s. 12.1 informationAsk for the personal information used, the reasons and the principal factors and parameters that led to the decision, and how to have the information corrected.
    3. 3Check and correctCompare what you receive with your own records. If anything is wrong or out of date, ask for a correction and include evidence.
    4. 4Ask for a review by a personAsk to present your observations to a staff member who is in a position to review the decision, and explain what you want reconsidered.
    5. 5Escalate if it is not resolvedUse the business's complaint process and contact the CAI. If it's a bank, you can go to OBSI after 56 days or once the bank's process ends.

    Questions people ask

    Does s. 12.1 apply to my bank?

    It depends on whether the bank is subject to Quebec's private-sector privacy act for that activity, which can be complex for federally regulated institutions. Ask the bank which law it applies, and contact the CAI if you need guidance.

    What if a person reviewed the decision?

    Section 12.1 is written for decisions based exclusively on automated processing. If a person took part, ask the business how it views the decision and what other options you have, such as a complaint or an access request.

    Will the business have to show me its algorithm?

    On request, the section requires the reasons and the principal factors and parameters that led to the decision. It doesn't say the business must hand over its full model or code.

    Is there a similar federal right?

    Not one in force. Bill C-36 proposes a right to an explanation of automated decisions with significant effects, but as of October 2026 it hasn't passed.

    When did s. 12.1 take effect?

    September 22, 2023, the day several Law 25 provisions came into force, according to the CAI.

    Educational information only, not financial, legal or privacy advice. Rules and bank features change; check the linked official pages and talk to your financial institution or a qualified professional about your situation.

    Keep reading

    Related guides

    Get the quarterly Canadian Bank AI Index update

    New scores, new deployments and rule changes, once a quarter from the MITEY Network. Unsubscribe any time.

    Educational information only, not financial, legal or privacy advice. Index scores measure public evidence, not service, safety or fairness. If you think you have been scammed, contact your financial institution right away and report it to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre at 1-888-495-8501. Last reviewed November 1, 2026.